“Men in suits should not undo what boys in uniform have
achieved.” Gary Alan Fine
I don’t follow college football or college sports in
general. The annual Bowl season, yawn; March Madness, snooze. When it comes to
the NCAA’s big money makers, football and basketball, I’m not sure the term
“scholar-athlete” carries any meaning. Gobs of money are made from the talent
and skill of athletes who receive no remuneration for their efforts and have no
rights or voice in the games they play. Talk about a feudal system.
I think I lost interest in college football when the number
of bowl games proliferated to the point they became a meaningless collection of
corporate advertising opportunities. It seems ancient history when the Rose
Bowl was simply the Rose Bowl; now it’s the (insert name of major corporate
sponsor here) Rose Bowl. Or Sugar Bowl. Or Fiesta Bowl. Take your pick.
Big time college sports in general, and football in
particular, spiraled out of control years ago, driven by the American public’s love
and a sophisticated promotion machine run by the NCAA that transformed athletic
programs at major universities into hugely profitable enterprises. As a result,
coaches at athletic powerhouses became highly paid, iconic and untouchable
figures. The likes of Woody Hayes, Bobby Knight and Jerry Tarkanian are allowed
to make fools of themselves on the sidelines, berating opposing players and
referees, throwing chairs, or screaming obscenities at their own players,
almost always without sanction because these, and other big name coaches, bring
championship hardware home, which equates to prestige and cash for their
schools and programs.
In keeping with the American Way, winning justifies aberrant
behavior.
As I have a general bias against college sports, I didn’t
follow the Penn State-Jerry Sandusky-Joe Paterno scandal very closely. I heard
the lewd allegations on the morning news, watched video of Jerry Sandusky
climbing in and out of a black SUV, and saw file footage of storied coach Joe
Paterno leading his Nittany Lions to glory – all before he turned a blind eye
and a deaf ear to the evil deeds being perpetrated in his own kingdom.
When Paterno died it was as if a head of state or the Pope
had passed away, and for me the excessive media coverage of the funeral was
emblematic of the outsized significance afforded college athletics. No question
about it, Joe Paterno was a great football coach, but it’s not like he
discovered the cure for HIV or led a social movement to guarantee civil rights
for an oppressed minority or changed our conception of the universe; unfortunately,
the American media doesn’t make much of an effort to place events and
personalities in the proper perspective.
Former FBI Director Louis Freeh conducted an investigation
on the cover-up and issued a report clearly indicting the adults involved for
placing their own interests before those of young men. Earlier this week, the governing
body of American college athletics, the NCAA, handed down its punishment. Most
people focused immediately on the monetary aspect of the sanctions -- $60
million – but what captured my attention was threefold. First, the effort the
NCAA made to protect its brand -- all that high-minded rhetoric by CEO Mark
Emmert about athletics never again being allowed to overshadow academics.
Seriously? Worshipping athletics at the expense of academics is exactly what
fills university coffers with coin. Second, the sanction eliminating
scholarships for athletes who were exiting nursery school when Jerry Sandusky
was buggering boys in the Penn State locker room. Why slam the doors of
opportunity on innocent kids? Punish the adults who were so intent on
protecting their reputations, the good name of the university, and the money
machine, but leave the innocent kids alone. Third, the NCAA’s sweeping decree
erasing fourteen years of Penn State football history from the record books.
Poof, in one fell swoop, all those games never happened, don’t count, and
cannot be considered part of Joe Paterno’s legacy. As Gary Alan Fine noted in a
New York Times editorial, George Orwell’s Ministry of Truth would approve.
Despite the NCAA’s actions, Penn State football will
recover. Relatively speaking, $60 million is a drop in the bucket. The white
men who run the NCAA empire will pat themselves on the back for swiftly
disciplining a rogue athletic program, but until the too-big-to-fail nature of
college athletics is rectified, little will change.
Until the day arrives when professors and graduate teaching
assistants earn more than football or basketball coaches, the NCAA cannot claim
with any credibility that academics are more important than athletics.